LOCAL HEROES

How Choice Fitness and Choice Fitness Elite built a culture of belonging.


BY JULIE KING

Among fitness centers, competitive advantage is typically attributed to equipment, programming, pricing, or amenities.

But Choice Fitness and Choice Fitness Elite have built something that’s more difficult to replicate. The company deliberately weaves community into its operational design across 10 locations in Massachusetts so members are consistently welcomed, recognized, and supported.

“Fitness is personal, but success often depends on connection, accountability, and belonging,” says Jason Ruggiero, CEO of Choice Fitness and Choice Fitness Elite. “Operators who focus only on equipment and pricing are competing as commodities.”

At Choice, a growing network of recurring touchpoints, such as group exercise, recreational sports, family programming, and local partnerships, offers members multiple opportunities to connect—and increases the likelihood they’ll return. That means stronger differentiation, engagement, and retention.

Ruggiero


“Our amenities are intentionally designed to bring people together. … Consumers are looking for authenticity, inclusiveness, and real human connection.” • Jason Ruggiero

CF Cares: Aligning With Local Charities

Beyond its four walls, Choice has formalized its commitment to local communities through CF Cares. Formed in 2019, CF Cares is a structured initiative for charitable partnerships and support.

“Like most local businesses, we’re solicited all the time for donations from nonprofit organizations,” Ruggiero explains. “We wanted to create an organized effort that had the greatest impact in the communities of each of our locations.”

Organizations must complete an application to be considered for support. Leadership team members review applications, often with input from club managers and staff who have direct connections to the organizations involved.

Decisions are based on community impact, alignment with company values, opportunities for member involvement, and the potential to create meaningful outcomes. Some years feature a broad range of smaller initiatives, while others focus on a select number of larger partnerships and fundraising efforts.

CF Cares often supports causes that have a personal connection for members. Fundraising efforts benefiting organizations such as the Dana-Farber Cancer Institute, the ALS Association, and the Alzheimer's Association resonate because they support issues that have affected many families in the communities Choice serves.

“CF Cares has been one of our most meaningful initiatives,” Ruggiero adds. “We focus on health, cancer research, youth development, and community wellness organizations.”

Long-Term Investment

The organization views the cost of cultivating community as a long-term investment in member experience, retention, and brand reputation—rather than simply a marketing expense.

“Community involvement has always been part of our business philosophy,” Ruggiero says. “Some efforts, like member appreciation days, in-club challenges, or charity drives, cost less than a few hundred dollars, while larger events involving partnerships, activations, or promotions require more investment.”

Choice Fitness evaluates the success of its efforts based on metrics such as:

● Retention

● Referrals

● Guest visits

● Participation levels

● Lead generation

● Ancillary revenue impact

But it’s not all about the numbers.

“Consumers are looking for authenticity, inclusiveness, and real human connection,” Ruggiero says. “People value in-person interaction more than ever, but they also want flexibility and environments that feel welcoming rather than transactional. The most successful community initiatives today feel genuine—recognizing member milestones, creating social fitness opportunities, supporting local causes, and giving members reasons to engage beyond just their workout.”

Why Connection Counts

In an industry where equipment can be replicated, pricing matched, and programming licensed, building relationships and fostering real community as part of the business model is a powerful differentiator.

“Choice Fitness is more than a place to exercise; it’s where people can build meaningful connections and make a positive impact,” Ruggiero says.

The result is often visible in member experiences. Many people initially join for fitness but remain because of the relationships they develop through group fitness classes, pickleball leagues, and club events, he says.

And members who were initially intimidated by the gym environment gain confidence through support from staff and other members—and eventually become active participants who mentor new members.

“Community ultimately means we support everyone, not just as gym members but as people,” Ruggiero says. “Operators who build community create relationships—and relationships drive retention, referrals, long-term brand loyalty, and stronger lifetime member value.”

Health & Fitness Business is a publication of

Health & Fitness Business (HFB) is the leading health and fitness industry publication. Published monthly by the Health & Fitness Association (HFA) and distributed free to the industry, HFB offers analysis of the opportunities, challenges, issues, and news that impact the industry.

Subscribe | Advertise | Past Issues | FAQs

©2026 Health & Fitness Association | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy

70 Fargo Street, Boston, MA 02210

1627 Street NW, Suite 1210, Washington DC, 20006